by Attorney William Bronchick
Foreclosure is the legal process of the mortgage holder taking the collateral for a promissory note in default. The process is slightly different from state to state, but there are basically two types of foreclosure, judicial and non-judicial. In mortgage states, judicial foreclosure is used, whereas, in Deed of Trust states, non-judicial foreclosure is used. Most states permit both types of proceedings, but it is common practice in most states to use exclusively one method or the other.
Judicial Foreclosure
Judicial foreclosure is a lawsuit that the lender (“mortgagee”) brings against the borrower (“mortgagor”) to get the property. About half of the states use judicial foreclosure. Like all lawsuits, it starts with a summons and complaint served upon the borrower and any other parties with inferior rights in the property (remember, all junior liens, including tenancies, are wiped out by the foreclosure).
If the borrower does not file an answer to the lawsuit, the lender gets a judgment by default. A referee is then appointed by the court to compute the total amount (including interest and attorney’s fees) that is due. The lender then must advertise a notice of sale in the newspaper for four to six weeks. If the total amount due is not paid, a public sale is conducted by the referee on the courthouse steps. The entire process can take as little as three months and as much as twelve months depending on the volume of court cases in your county.
The sale is conducted like an auction, the property going to the highest bidder. Unless there is significant equity in the property, the only bidder at the sale will be a representative of the lender. The lender can bid up to the amount it is owed, without having to actually come out of pocket to purchase the property.
If the proceeds from the sale are insufficient to satisfy the amount owed to the lender, the lender may be entitled to a deficiency judgment against the borrower and anyone else who guaranteed the loan. Some states prohibit a lender from obtaining a deficiency judgment against a borrower (See, e.g., Alaska Statutes §34.20.100, Washington Revised Code §61.24.010, California Code of Civil Procedure §580b)
Non-Judicial Foreclosure
Most states permit a lender to foreclose without a lawsuit, using what is commonly called a “power of sale.” Rather than a mortgage, the borrower (“grantor”) gives a “deed of trust” to a trustee to hold for the lender (“beneficiary”). Upon default, the lender simply files a notice of default and a notice of sale, which is published in the newspaper. The entire process usually takes about 90 days. The borrower usually has a right of redemption after the sale (see below).
Strict Foreclosure
A few states permit “strict” foreclosure, which does not require a sale. When the proceeding is started, the borrower has a certain amount of time to pay what is owed. Once the date has passed, title reverts to the lender. Many California and Oregon cases, in which the seller has sought forfeiture under a land contract, the court has ordered a strict foreclosure. See, e.g., Peterson v. Hartell, 707 P.2d 232 (1985), Zimmerman v. Estate of Cook, 855 P.2d 193 (Oregon 1993).
Reinstating the Loan
Many states permit a borrower to “cure” the loan before the date of sale. This simply requires paying the amount in arrears, plus interest and attorney’s fees. It is certainly more desirable for a defaulting borrower to reinstate a loan rather than pay off the entire principal balance.
Virtually all states have specific laws requiring a reasonable notice to the defaulting borrower before the lender can accelerate the debt. If you are a lender, make sure you review the default notice with your attorney to ensure compliance with state law. If your attorney or other party sends the notice, be sure he complies with the Federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (See, Romea v. Heiberger & Associates, 97 Civ. 4681 (S.D.N.Y. 1998); Law firm held liable for violation of F.D.P.C.A. by signing 3-day demand for rent).
Redemption Rights
Some states give a borrower the right to “redeem” the amount owed and get title to the property back after the sale. The length of the redemption period changes from state to state. The highest right of redemption is from the owner, borrower or guarantor on the note. Behind him come the junior lien holders who are in danger of being wiped out by the foreclosing senior lien holder.
In states where there is a long redemption period, investors often buy the junior liens on the property to have the right to redeem the property from foreclosure. The holder of the most junior lien has the last right to redeem the property by paying off all underlying liens. The owner, of course, has the highest right. Obtaining a quitclaim deed from the owner gives you the right to redeem the property yourself.
If you are new to the foreclosure game, having a good mentor or real estate attorney that knows this process is paramount.
